Anderson & Boback Logo

Religious-upbringing Clause in Marital Settlement Agreement

Published
Categorized as Child Custody & Visitation, Divorce, Divorce Litigation

Religious-upbringing Clause Almost Cost an Ex-Hasidic Mom Custody of Her Three Children

During the divorce process, most parents come to an agreement about how to raise their children. For the most part, this agreement is based on the way the parents were raised, or the way the parties planned on raising their children. For two Hasidic parents in New York, it was not out of the ordinary for them to agree upon their divorce that the religious-upbringing of the children would be in the Hasidic religion. However, a couple of years later, the mother came out to her family and children as lesbian and moved in with a transgender man. The news shocked her conservative religious community and caused her ex-husband to seek emergency custody of their three children.

Impact of Religious-upbringing Clause

To the mother’s surprise, the trial judge granted the emergency motion, granted the father custody of the children, and forbade the mother from discussing her sexuality with her youngest children. After a long battle and an appeal to the Appellate Court, the children were given back to the mother so long as she maintains a kosher home and keeps the children in Hasidic schools.

This story serves as a caution both to parents and divorce attorneys when they are drafting Marital Settlement Agreements. Although specificity can make Marital Settlement Agreements more enforceable and provides clarity, it can also pigeon hole the parties into complying with its provisions for years after the agreement. If the parties agreed to raise the children Catholic even though neither party is particularly religious, the parents may be restricted from changing their children’s religion because of these provisions. The same goes for extracurricular activities, daycare, and other provisions that may no longer be relevant a few years after the entry of the agreement. The provisions can always be changed by agreement, but it may cost the parties attorneys’ fees and a big headache to make these changes.

As to this particular case, regardless of the provisions stated in the Marital Settlement Agreement, the trial court imposed its own morality and found that the mother’s new lifestyle clashed with her agreement to raise the children in the Hasidic faith. While that may be true, the terms of the agreement did not dictate that the mother herself would continue in the Hasidic faith. In addition, she agreed to continue raising her children in the Hasidic faith. As a result, as the Appellate Court held, the children could remain in the mother’s care so long as she continues to abide by the religious-upbringing clause agreeing to raise the children in that particular faith.

Was this information helpful?

You May Also Like

Wonder if your spousal maintenance is modifiable? This question was addressed in Scarp v. Rahman when the father in the case of sought to modify his maintenance obligation.  The trial court would not allow the modification so he sought an…

Birthdays are a big deal to kids - they usually get a party with their friends with cake, balloons, presents, and if they are lucky, a ball pit to jump into at Chucky Cheese! The day is all about them.…

Our firm represents a lot of military families and for the most part, handling a military divorce is just like any other divorce.  There are specific rules that need to be followed, however, and those parents in the military facing…

Changes to Spousal Maintenance Law in Illinois In 2019, a significant change in the tax code was made regarding maintenance, which resulted in spousal maintenance (formerly known as “alimony”, also known as “spousal support”) being tax-free to the recipient and…

Illinois has modified its statutes wherein parents are now allocated “parental responsibilities” and “parenting time” instead of “custody”.  The purpose of these changes was to try and give the parents less to fight over.  You can win “custody” but winning…

For Illinois parents that are no longer together or facing divorce, understanding the basics of child custody law is important. First, the term “custody” no longer exists in Illinois. The State of Illinois changed its laws regarding custody in 2016,…

RECENT POST
Categories
Archives
Anderson & Boback small logo

Download our Divorce Planning Guide today!

Get the information you need to prepare for divorce with our free resource Guide to Planning for Your Divorce.

What our clients are saying

Schedule a Discreet Consultation Today!

    Firm Overview
    ANDERSON & BOBACK

    Anderson & Boback is a highly-respected, experienced Chicago family law firm, skilled in negotiation and litigation. When divorce and other family law issues make your life chaotic and uncertain, you want your case resolved as quickly and fairly as possible. Call Now 312-715-0870