Anderson & Boback Logo

Appellate Court Reverses Termination of Permanent Maintenance

Published
Categorized as Spousal Support

Permanent maintenance is often granted when the parties had a long marriage and there is no termination date in site. However, permanent maintenance does not necessarily mean it can never be terminated. Permanent maintenance can be reviewed after a certain period of time.  It can be modified/terminated at any time after a finding of a substantial change in circumstances

In In re the Marriage of Bernay, 2017 IL App (2d) 160583, the trial court had ordered the husband to pay wife permanent maintenance in the amount of $3,600 per month. Said maintenance would terminate only upon either party’s death or upon Lynn’s remarriage or participation in a conjugal relationship. In 2014, the husband petitioned to terminate wife’s maintenance alleging that his income had decreased and he wished to retire within 12 months. The husband had also been diagnosed with lymphoma which he cited as a basis for terminating the wife’s maintenance. The trial granted the husband’s motion to terminate and the wife appealed. The appellate court in a recent decision reversed the trial court’s decision to terminate maintenance and reinstated the maintenance award.

The court in Bernay found that permanent maintenance is awarded in cases where the recipient spouse is either unemployable or employable only at an income considerably lower than the standard of living established during the marriage. Furthermore, the court found that even permanent maintenance is modifiable based on a finding of a substantial change of circumstances. However, the court found that the trial court had improperly ignored prior court orders regarding the parties’ standard of living. More importantly, the court found that the permanent maintenance award was granted at a time when the parties were in their fifties and retirement was “clearly contemplated” when the permanent maintenance award was granted. Furthermore, the court found that the husband had sufficient assets to continue to pay maintenance based on his extensive real estate portfolio worth approximately $1.1 million, $1.4 million in retirement accounts, and an expectation of $1.9 million from the estates of his recently deceased parents.

This decision seems to solidify permanent maintenance awards and reduce the possibility of termination unless there are extenuating circumstances that not only significantly change the financial picture of the parties but that were also not expected at the time the award was made. It is difficult for me to understand how a court could find that a maintenance award when the parties are in their fifties automatically takes into account that at least one of the parties could retire in 10 years. The party could’ve been in their best earning years in their fifties which could’ve led to a very high maintenance award without contemplating retirement. Or, a party could decide not to retire until they are in their 70’s or 80’s, which would make it unfair to take this into consideration when the parties are in their fifties.

Whatever the case may be, it is probably advisable that the parties outline the factors considered in a divorce, or even stipulate that this award does not contemplate retirement. Or, if possible, avoid the term “permanent” and instead focus on making an award reviewable. If you are in this situation, talk to an experienced attorney who can help word a settlement agreement to your benefit.

Was this information helpful?

You May Also Like

When a couple is considering a divorce, oftentimes there is a discussion about the house and who will live there during the divorce process.  Whether it is rented or purchased, some people decide that they would like to remain living…

Typically, you’d want to avoid a default when you are going through a divorce in Chicago because if not, then the way your marital estate is divided is out of your hands. Recently a client hired us to help her…

Spousal support is often a contentious issue in marriages that are substantial in length, where one spouse has outearned the other spouse.  Spousal support (formerly called alimony and often referred to as maintenance) is the payment of money from one…

There is a lot of disagreement about vaccinations for children and the argument between parents with differing views on this subject is not a new one.  Illinois family law attorneys representing parents in this type of disagreement have worked throughout…

There are many things that parents do when they are going through a separation from a partner or a divorce where a parent could lose custody - or impact their rights to make decisions for their minor children going forward,…

In my experience as a Chicago divorce attorney, when it comes to which spouse initiates a divorce in a marriage it is more often the wife.  Of course, there are plenty of husbands who file for divorce but in a…

RECENT POST
Categories
Archives
Anderson & Boback small logo

Download our Divorce Planning Guide today!

Get the information you need to prepare for divorce with our free resource Guide to Planning for Your Divorce.

What our clients are saying

Why Choose
ANDERSON & BOBACK?

Schedule a Discreet Consultation Today!

    Firm Overview
    ANDERSON & BOBACK?

    Anderson & Boback is a highly-respected, experienced Chicago family law firm, skilled in negotiation and litigation. When divorce and other family law issues make your life chaotic and uncertain, you want your case resolved as quickly and fairly as possible. Call Now 312-715-0870