Anderson & Boback Logo
smart home technology evidence in Family law divorce

Using Smart Home Evidence in Family Law Cases

Published
Categorized as Illinois Family Law

Smart Home technology is all the rage lately.  Everyone seems to have a digital device, whether it be  Siri on an iPhone, a Google Home, an Alexa, Ring security cameras, doorbell cameras, and more.  While this smart home technology certainly can make our lives easier, the way these devices can impact court proceedings is widely unknown.  In criminal proceedings, subpoenas have been issued to try and obtain the recordings from smart devices to large companies such as Google, or Amazon, but the issues largely are resolved before any of these large companies have to comply.  In Illinois, family law and divorce cases use these devices a bit differently.

Obtaining Smart Home Recordings

There are two ways to obtain recordings on Smart devices. The first way is through the use of a Subpoena. Subpoenas are largely unsuccessful unless the litigants have the funds to retain an attorney in the state where the company being subpoenaed is registered in order to pursue a separate cause of action to obtaining the recordings, records, and/or videos sought.  The second way to obtain these recordings is to request them in the discovery from the person who has access to them.  For Smart Home devices like home security cameras and doorbell cameras, the person who resides in the home or has access to the accounts may be able to produce the videos and/or recordings if they are requested within the time period where the recordings are saved.  This is typically the most cost-effective way to obtain these recordings, but the time frame in which the recordings are stored can be quite short, so it is important to copy them or request them as soon as possible after the event in question.

Recordings from Your Own Smart Devices

A person can use their own recording from their own devices in Court so long as they are able to lay a foundation for the evidence.  This means that they have to be able to prove that the video is authentic, was not altered or doctored in any way, and that it was not altered in the chain of custody. 

In family law cases, this is usually simple to do.  Someone produces a video.  Let’s say it is a neighbor who produced their doorbell footage of you and your spouse arguing on your front lawn.  The neighbor can produce the video via subpoena, or can voluntarily produce it.  The neighbor can be subpoenaed to testify that:

  • they were watching the event as it was recorded live,
  • that their camera recorded the same event that they witnessed,
  • how they downloaded the video onto some sort of device, and
  • send it to the attorney, etc. 

The testimony of the neighbor is usually enough for the video to come into evidence in a family court case and then the court will review the footage, which should corroborate the story told by the parties in the case and the neighbor.  

Recordings from Doorbell Cameras

A person can also use their own home footage as well, from security cameras, a Ring doorbell, etc.  This is true especially when the spouse has a reasonable expectation that they are being recorded (they know about the doorbell camera, for example, or they can see it because it is out in the open and should have known about it.)  This is different than a covertly planted camera the spouse is unaware of.  People have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their own homes and recording or surveilling a spouse without their knowledge or consent wouldn’t likely be admissible in proceedings.  However, when a spouse knows the recording device is there and consents to it, that footage is typically fair game.

People do really crazy things in front of doorbell cameras.  It can capture exchanges of children for parenting time, exchanges of money for support, conversations between estranged spouses or exes, and more.  People tend to forget they are there.  However, the footage can be helpful in certain situations and could be admitted in a family law case.

Anderson & Boback
Anderson & Boback has the legal expertise you need to formulate a winning strategy in your family law case, including using Smart Home recordings. Contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation and speak with a top Chicago family law attorney.

Was this information helpful?

You May Also Like

Wonder if your spousal maintenance is modifiable? This question was addressed in Scarp v. Rahman when the father in the case of sought to modify his maintenance obligation.  The trial court would not allow the modification so he sought an…

Birthdays are a big deal to kids - they usually get a party with their friends with cake, balloons, presents, and if they are lucky, a ball pit to jump into at Chucky Cheese! The day is all about them.…

Our firm represents a lot of military families and for the most part, handling a military divorce is just like any other divorce.  There are specific rules that need to be followed, however, and those parents in the military facing…

Changes to Spousal Maintenance Law in Illinois In 2019, a significant change in the tax code was made regarding maintenance, which resulted in spousal maintenance (formerly known as “alimony”, also known as “spousal support”) being tax-free to the recipient and…

Illinois has modified its statutes wherein parents are now allocated “parental responsibilities” and “parenting time” instead of “custody”.  The purpose of these changes was to try and give the parents less to fight over.  You can win “custody” but winning…

For Illinois parents that are no longer together or facing divorce, understanding the basics of child custody law is important. First, the term “custody” no longer exists in Illinois. The State of Illinois changed its laws regarding custody in 2016,…

RECENT POST
Categories
Archives
Anderson & Boback small logo

Download our Divorce Planning Guide today!

Get the information you need to prepare for divorce with our free resource Guide to Planning for Your Divorce.

What our clients are saying

Schedule a Discreet Consultation Today!

    Firm Overview
    ANDERSON & BOBACK

    Anderson & Boback is a highly-respected, experienced Chicago family law firm, skilled in negotiation and litigation. When divorce and other family law issues make your life chaotic and uncertain, you want your case resolved as quickly and fairly as possible. Call Now 312-715-0870